Etsy Reviews for Mystic Pigeon Gaming
Etsy Reviews
I have been on Etsy for over 7 years (as of November 2026), with over 17.5k sales and over 4k reviews where I maintain an average review rating of 4.8 over the 7 years I have been on Etsy. So I have been established for a fair while now! Check out the reviews for yourself. So why the new website? A common saying: don't put all your eggs in one basket; well, that's basically why I have made a new website. But more than driving sales, I want to create a central hub where people can see my physical minis and terrain, digital offerings, and find a community for build guides, painting guides, and to talk to other people interested in similar models.
★★★★★ 4.8 / 5
4,000+ Etsy Verified Reviews
Over 17.5k sales on Etsy
From our Etsy shop
What Our Customers Say
★
5
/ 5
A few small pieces missing becomes not take away from over all purchase.
Matthew
Nov 17, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Loved it. Wonderful quality and customizability.
Chris
Nov 15, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Looks great on my board!!
Kerri
Nov 13, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Looks great on my board!!
Kerri
Nov 13, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Amazing quality. Highly recommended ð
Andy
Nov 13, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Amazing quality. Highly recommended ð
Andy
Nov 13, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Looks great on my board!!
Kerri
Nov 13, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Great items, perfect size for the scale Iâm using. Prompt delivery. Would happily buy from this seller again.
Kev
Nov 12, 2026
★
4
/ 5
nice product that helped develop a perfect diorama.
philnartey
Nov 7, 2026
★
5
/ 5
An all-round fantastic transaction! Cannot recommend this seller enough. A****
Ross
Nov 5, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Amazingly detailed item and fun project
Luke
Nov 3, 2026
★
3
/ 5
The item was stuck in customs and so I never received the item. Requested refund. Per seller instruction I had to go through Etsy insurance if I wanted to receive a refund.
Chris
Oct 25, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Great Stargate for my jumping spider habitat! It arrived unpainted, so I can decide the colors myself. I love this so much! Lord Dao will love it, too, when he comes out of molt! Great product and great communication with the seller. Highly recommend!
Lady
Oct 23, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Well made and seller was helpful, highly recommend if youâre looking for some scatter terrain
Sign in with Apple user
Oct 22, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Cleverly made to be both textured and practical - I've found them very handy for use in D&S when I need a bit of variety
Harry
Oct 20, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Really fast delivery, well packaged and items exactly as described with a good quality.
Matthew
Oct 19, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Perfect thank you well made just the right size I need fast delivery thanks
Anjanette
Oct 19, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Great seller, really fast delivery, well packaged and exactly as listed. Perfect model, in multiple parts for easy painting. 10/10
Matthew
Oct 19, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Emballage de la figure médiocre, mettez du papier bulle plutôt qu'une feuille de papier, sinon figurine magnifique, très belle résine.
marc
Oct 18, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Beautifully made and very detailed. Really brings the tabletop to life!
rossyung
Oct 17, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Beautifully made and very detailed. Really brings the tabletop to life!
rossyung
Oct 17, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Beautifully made and very detailed. Really brings the tabletop to life!
rossyung
Oct 17, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Great product, very flexible
James
Oct 14, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Awesome, prompt, great packaging, smooth and breezy
Evan
Oct 6, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Really great set of terrain which is going to go a long way to making my table look much nicer. They came very quickly, and were packaged well so arrived in perfect shape. I will absolutely be buying more!
D
Oct 1, 2026
★
4
/ 5
Ordered this awhile ago, and forgot what I ordered only reason 4* is I ordered the hamster ball and got the doom wheel, looks awesome needed bit of clean up but only odd swarf missed I already started building it before I realised I didn't order it and I still have the look I'm going for so no complaints and as I said looks awesome
Sam
Sep 29, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Perfect gift for a dnd fan
karenmale
Sep 27, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Amazig quality, measurements are accurate, really nice!
Arjun Sahmbi
Sep 26, 2026
★
5
/ 5
The terrain was crafted well and arrived very promptly!
Alex
Sep 23, 2026
★
5
/ 5
These were made really well and all the numbers are clearly visible which is great when you have a battle map full of stuff. My party absolutely loved them and agreed it was a worthwhile investment for our DnD games - definitely beat our original task of sticking tiny laminated squares to the bottom of minis with the npc number. We have had many play sessions with them and they are still holding strong and looking good. one alteration I made was i cut out and stuck some magnetic sheeting into the squares as our minis all have tiny magnets on the bottom so this helped them stay secure in the marker whenever they needing moving instead of toppling over.
Bo Jack
Sep 23, 2026
★
5
/ 5
The terrain was crafted well and arrived very promptly!
Alex
Sep 23, 2026
★
5
/ 5
these are very cool
Adam
Sep 23, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Everything came as described. The quality is great and the sculpt is gorgeous. Thank you very much!
hungphamclip
Sep 21, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Excellent item, good value and easy to build
Craig
Sep 20, 2026
★
5
/ 5
The dice jail works on naughty dice.
Jonathon
Sep 15, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Great item, well made ð
sillycat
Sep 14, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Customer service is amazing!!! I was accidentally sent the wrong order. I sent a message to explain what had happened. They were quick to respond and couldnât have been more helpful. They took no time in sending me out a replacement parcel which arrived promptly. As for the rocks themselves, what can I say, the quality is absolutely amazing!! I would definitely recommend to anyone looking to enhance their terrain for wargaming. If youâre someone like me who doesnât have a lot of time to build terrain these are ideal and they donât break the bank! Great quality at a great price, put that together with brilliant customer service. What more could you want.
Sign in with Apple user
Sep 14, 2026
★
5
/ 5
This is such a fun item, bought as a gift and they loved it. Shipped quickly and was packaged really well ð
sillycat
Sep 14, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Really funny gift it came in quite a large box which was hilarious to open. Fun all around
Lucy
Sep 11, 2026
★
5
/ 5
I had to ask some questions about this item and I got clear, timely responses. The item itself is very well made and is a cool design. Very easy seller to work with and the item is great, many thanks.
Sarah
Sep 10, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Well packed (letterbox friendly) and arrived quickly. For such small items, the level of detail in each one is incredible! In the pack of four, each one was slightly different. Looking forward to painting them. Very happy to recommend and will be back for more pieces soon.
MáirtÃn
Sep 10, 2026
★
5
/ 5
N/A
Ryan
Sep 9, 2026
★
5
/ 5
N/A
Ryan
Sep 9, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Previous post comment.
Ryan
Sep 9, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Terrain is great, as is the cost, only comment is could add is if they could be coated with a thin layer of matt scenery varnish.
Ryan
Sep 9, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Kent was super helpful and provided a custom print service for my Heroquest board game. I am really looking forward to the next gaming night to introduce these and give some of them a try. I'm sure they will go down a treat! Kent was also quick to respond and provided good communication and fast delivery. Excellent service! Recommended.
Chi-Lung
Sep 7, 2026
★
3
/ 5
Size of rocks are smaller than expected. Quality is nice as the rocks look realistic and are crafted beautifully , but the texture easily comes off. Overall my opinion is for the price itâs not worth it. Also i am confused to what I actually i ordered versus what I received. And I cannot locate the exact purchases on Etsy. I thought I bought 6 rocks in 2 separate orders but only recieved 4. Spent $110 and expected more.
Pete
Sep 6, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Superb model wih minimun clean up needed with an extremely fast delivery, looking forward to seeing it on a battlefild
Keith Toyne
Sep 4, 2026
★
5
/ 5
The ship is very well crafted and arrived super fast
Sabine
Sep 4, 2026
★
5
/ 5
Really nice design, was very well packaged and delivered very quickly.
Katie
Sep 3, 2026
The Mystic Pigeon Gaming Newsletter
Join the Squab Warband
Sign up to hear about new product releases, painting and hobby updates, campaign inspiration, and special offers from Mystic Pigeon Gaming, straight to your inbox.
